Categories: Environment

What will global leaders at this week’s UN climate summit be eating? A whole lot of meat

On Monday, delegates in Poland met for the United Nations’ annual climate conference, dubbed COP24. This is the same conference that in 2015 led to the Paris Climate Accord, which the United States has since decided to abandon.

Reporters were quick to point out the ironies inherent in this year’s conference siting. In Katowice, Poland, a city built on coal mining, attendees will listen to panels in rooms heated by coal, in a city with elevated levels of air pollution.  

It’s clear we have a long way to go. And that’s perhaps fitting against the backdrop of recent climate-related headlines: Catastrophic damage will unfold sooner than we realized. We’re already feeling the social, economic, and political impacts of a warming globe. And, oh yeah, we have just 10 years to turn things around.

If everyone at the COP24 ate meat, they could collectively consume the energy equivalent of half-a-million gallons of gas.

Of course, the energy sector remains the single largest contributor to global warming, accounting for 72 percent of global emissions in 2013. But there’s a growing acknowledgement among advocates that meeting emissions goals means paying attention to other industries, too. The agriculture sector alone, for instance, is responsible for 9 percent of U.S. emissions.

Related Post

That’s why food and farming advocates are disappointed by the decidedly emissions-heavy menu offerings at COP24. According to research by non-profit groups Farm Forward, the Center for Biological Diversity, and BrighterGreen, attendees’ meat-based options outnumber vegetarian dishes at a rate of two to one. If everyone at the conference opted for the meat choice, they would collectively consume the energy equivalent of half-a-million gallons of gas.

Had the organizers of an international climate conference opted for a meat-free menu, the logic goes, it would’ve signaled that mainstream policymakers are ready to consider the role meat consumption plays in a warming globe. But it seems we’re not quite there yet. A quick glance at the COP24 schedule shows that food and farming issues aren’t really on the table at all. (Bloomberg points out that one ancillary event does address food systems.)

Yet, advocates argue, the environmental impact of meat consumption is much larger than the oft-cited 9 percent of emissions that come from the farm. When you account for the energy used to ship animal feed from the U.S. to China, and the energy used to dispose of wasted food, the equation looks a lot different. Expand that definition to account for the whole supply chain, including the energy used to make fertilizer, and animal agriculture’s environmental impact looks enormous. As we reported  in July, one study found that the top five meat and dairy companies use more carbon than Exxon, Shell, or BP.

Barring a convincing, dirt-cheap meat alternative or the widespread buy-in of the big meat corporations, it’s not likely that meat consumption overall will substantially decline without government intervention. World leaders may eventually have to tax meat, cap farm emissions, or incentivize on-farm sequestration techniques.

But none of that is being discussed at this year’s COP24. We have to agree on how to carry out the three-year-old Paris Agreement before we can move on to the next thing. Perhaps that’s why meat is still on the menu.  

H. Claire Brown
Share
Published by
H. Claire Brown

Recent Posts

Is California giving its methane digesters too much credit?

Every year, California dairy farms emit hundreds of thousands of tons of the potent greenhouse…

2 years ago

Your car is killing coho salmon

Highway 7 runs north-south through western Washington, carving its way through a landscape sparsely dotted…

2 years ago

The pandemic has transformed America’s dining landscape into an oligopoly dominated by chains 

One of the greatest pleasures I had as a child growing up in the Chicago…

2 years ago

California is moving toward food assistance for all populations—including undocumented immigrants

Undocumented immigrants experience food insecurity at much higher rates than other populations, yet they are…

2 years ago

Babka, borscht … and pumpkin spice? Two writers talk about Jewish identity through contemporary cookbooks.

Writer Charlotte Druckman and editor Rebecca Flint Marx are both Jewish journalists living in New…

2 years ago

How some big grocery chains help ensure that food deserts stay barren

Last fall, first-year law student Karissa Kang arrived at Yale University and quickly set out…

2 years ago