Google added a big blue “Order Online” button to many of its restaurant listings. Restaurant owners wish it would go away.

For Annie Miler, the owner of well-reviewed lunch spot Clementine in Los Angeles, the new function came as a shock. “At first I was like, oh, cool, a big order button,” she said when I reached her while she shopped for back-to-school supplies with her kids. She assumed it would link to Clementine’s in-house ordering system. “But then when I clicked on it, I kind of flipped out because it’s linked to a very generic-looking page … that said ‘order from Postmates,’” she added. Postmates takes a 10-percent marketing commission for every pickup order at her restaurant, and 30 percent when it facilitates delivery. The button was misleading—it made it appear like Postmates was the only delivery option, so every click routed profit away from Miler’s restaurant.

Realizing the button would eat into her bottom line by tossing commissions to Postmates, Miler tried to get it removed. She uses a Google-owned service called Google My Business to edit the card that appears in Google Maps and on the right-hand side of the screen in Google searches. (You’d recognize this card—it displays a few pictures, the restaurant’s starred user rating, and its address, phone number, and operating hours.) But when Miler called Google My Business to ask them to remove the button, she was directed to call Postmates instead. Miler does have a contract with Postmates; she sees it as a marketing spend to attract new customers. But despite her working arrangement with Postmates, this had never been mentioned as part of the deal. And in some cases, Google’s button links to DoorDash, which does not have a relationship with every restaurant on its platform.

Postmates gave her instructions to remove the button, but they didn’t work. Later, a representative sent her back to Google. Miler finally took matters into her own hands: Since the button only appeared during business hours, she adjusted her restaurant’s hours in the Postmates platform so it only appeared to be open about half an hour a week. The button finally disappeared, but so did any orders through Postmates. Miler soon started getting calls from customers, disappointed that delivery appeared unavailable.

Eventually, Miler got a clearer response from Postmates. “Unfortunately, we have no direct control,” a spokesperson wrote. “If you would like more direct control over your Google knowledge panel I recommend going to this link Google Claim Your Business. Furthermore, you would have to delete your menu off of your business page for this to take effect.”

A Google spokesperson tells The New Food Economy via email that, “Restaurant owners can reach out to Google My Business support channels at any time to modify their listing,” including removing the button. However, Miler’s attempts to get it removed have been unsuccessful. We’ve spoken to others in the restaurant industry who had the same experience.

When Google’s “Order Online” buttons appeared on Maps and Search listings in May, the press largely covered the change as a boon to small restaurants, quoting consultants who claimed the button would bring in new business. In reality, restaurant owners say they were caught off guard. The change has confused customers and privileged the large delivery platforms. The outcome, they say, is worse for both the restaurant and the eater.

~

Not all delivery platforms are created equal in the eyes of a restaurant owner. Some, like ChowNow, charge a single flat fee per month. Others, like Postmates and DoorDash, charge some combination of a flat delivery fee to the eater and a marketing commission to the restaurant based on a set percentage of each order. Many restaurant owners, including Miler, set up their own online ordering systems, which are generally cheaper and more bare-bones than the glitzy delivery apps.

Miler makes the most money when customers order in-person or on her own website. She makes a lot less when they order through Postmates. That’s why it was so important to her that the button come down: It was siphoning money to Postmates, even as it appeared on a search listing that looked like it represented Clementine. “It really burns me that they were diverting people who searched for us to place pickup orders through Postmates—at least for delivery orders we were paying Postmates for a service that we don’t offer otherwise,” Miller wrote in a follow-up email.

So why was it so hard to make the button go away? Miler obtained a document from ChowNow that sheds some light on the relationship between Google and its delivery platform partners. According to the document—which is essentially an FAQ for restaurant owners—restaurants are charged a 10 percent commission for every order placed through Google. A Google representative wrote in an email that it does not receive any commission.

ChowNow makes it pretty easy for restaurant owners to understand the implications of Google’s new button. It offers a “Profit Protector” program that essentially inflates menu prices to make up for the price of the commission. It also assures owners that they can opt out of ChowNow’s Google services anytime by contacting the platform’s support staff.

But opting out of ChowNow’s services doesn’t remove the blue button entirely. It might still display offers from other platforms like Postmates and DoorDash. And unlike ChowNow, the other platforms don’t appear to offer options to uncouple their services with Google. (Postmates and DoorDash did not respond to requests for comment by press time.)

A restaurant consultant in Los Angeles who works with between 45 and 60 restaurants has attempted to get the button removed on behalf of a handful of clients. She didn’t want to use her name in this story because she does not have permission to share her clients’ names. But the consultant says she’s called Google several times and has been redirected to the delivery platforms every time.

DoorDash representatives have told the consultant over and over again that they cannot remove restaurants from the Google listing without removing them from DoorDash entirely. In some cases, her restaurant clients had never signed up with DoorDash to begin with: The company was simply sending its delivery drivers to their stores. (DoorDash has been accused of this many times before, most recently in June.) That means that in some cases restaurants saw the button appear on their listing, linking exclusively to a service with which they had no relationship.

The consultant explained that this practice is confusing for customers: A restaurant that previously offered free delivery would suddenly appear, via Google’s “Order Online” button, to be charging $6 for delivery with DoorDash. Even though nothing has changed at the actual restaurant—the free delivery option is still available if the customer accesses the menu through the restaurant’s own website—a customer might reasonably assume the Google button was presenting all delivery options. The customer would realize this wasn’t the case if they investigated further, but food delivery is often a convenience game: An unexpected $6 delivery charge can make the difference between ordering in and subsisting on tortilla chips.

Miler says the button itself isn’t the only problem with the new ordering system. She also has no way of making sure the menu that appears on Google is up to date. And there are other, subtler, impacts. “It’s not just about my bottom line. It’s about the fact that we’re going to move toward a very generic experience,” she says. “[Google and delivery platforms] want a smooth user experience and they want you to be able to move through the world without having to have a slow-loading website, but by making everything float through and look the same, it’s depriving people of flavor.”